< Back to Blog

Easy Wild Blueberry Gingerbread Thumbprint Cookies

Although I habitually buy the December issue of Martha Stewart Magazine — dazzled by the promise of a spectacular Christmas on its cover — I’ve never actually made a single holiday craft within its pages. I want to. I really do. But anything that requires mail ordering craft materials or investing in new cooking supplies gives me pause. Plus, spending the day making wreaths out of fallen twigs or assembling three-dimensional cookies is more than I can handle in December. I gravitate towards kitchen crafts you can make in under an hour rather than under a day.

Enter the newest addition to my holiday baking repertoire: Wild Blueberry Gingerbread Thumbprint Cookies. A festive, easy and fun-to-make holiday cookie that marries the seasonal flavors of gingerbread with a quick homemade jam.  No exotic spices or expensive made-to-order cookie cutters needed, only a working thumb, an ordinary plastic baggie and some delicious frozen Wild Blueberries.

This recipe riffs off a popular old-fashioned one, where you roll the dough into small balls and hollow out the centers with the press of a thumb. In this new version, the cookies get filled with tasty homemade fruit preserves before going into the oven to bake. Making your own jam is really simple. For this recipe, all you do is stir together Wild Blueberries and chia seeds. The seeds work their magic on the fruit, transforming it into a Wild Blueberry jam that’s well-suited to the flavors of gingerbread.

Speaking of gingerbread – that’s another departure from the classic one for this recipe. I’ve used gingerbread dough instead of the traditional shortbread kind. Plus, this new interpretation derives much of its sweetness from less processed sources (Wild Blueberries and honey), and is made with whole-wheat flour rather than the all-purpose white variety.

The one element of this cookie that does channel a bit of that Martha spirit is the white chocolate drizzle. It’s a purely optional finishing touch that can be accomplished by filling a simple plastic bag with melted chocolate, snipping off a corner, and getting your drizzle on. No fancy equipment, rarified craft supplies, or mail-order ingredients required.

Get Great Recipes & More Each Month!

Sign up for occasional emails with recipes, health and nutrition tips, and more.